How to Set Up a Vintage Christmas Gift Tag Workshop Using Thrifted & Forgotten Treasures

Turn old Christmas cards, forgotten sheet music, fabric scraps, and everyday materials into beautiful handmade gift tags while creating a festive holiday tradition of your own.
This blog post contains affiliate links, including links to products on Amazon. If you make a purchase through one of these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Christmas has a funny way of making us believe we need to buy something new to make everything feel special. New decorations, new wrapping paper, new ribbons, and of course, those little packages of gift tags that somehow disappear before we've finished wrapping the presents.
But some of the prettiest holiday details can come from things we already have tucked away in drawers, closets, and forgotten boxes.
An old Christmas card with a beautiful illustration, a piece of lace from a sewing basket, a few pages of sheet music, or even a scrap of wallpaper can become something worth saving.
This year, why not turn those forgotten treasures into a little holiday tradition?
I'm talking about creating your very own Vintage Christmas Gift Tag Workshop, a cozy space where family and friends can gather, get creative, and make beautiful, one-of-a-kind gift tags without spending a fortune.
And the best part? You don't need to be particularly crafty to enjoy it. If you can cut paper, tie ribbon, and appreciate something with a little character, you're already qualified.
Why Create a Christmas Gift Tag Workshop?
If you've ever spent time browsing an antique store or digging through a box of old greeting cards at an estate sale, you know how much charm can be found in the smallest things.
Vintage illustrations, faded florals, delicate lace, and old-fashioned typography have a character that mass-produced decorations often lack.
A Christmas gift tag workshop gives us an opportunity to use those little treasures instead of letting them sit forgotten.
It's also a wonderful excuse to slow down during a season that can become terribly busy.
Invite a few friends over, put on some Christmas music, brew a pot of tea, and spend an afternoon making something beautiful together.
You can even ask everyone to bring a small collection of materials they no longer need. Old Christmas cards, ribbon remnants, buttons, fabric scraps, and decorative papers are all welcome.
Before long, you'll have a table filled with supplies, plenty of conversation, and a collection of handmade gift tags that no two people could ever make exactly alike.

A Little Prep Work Goes a Long Way
If you're planning to host a gift tag workshop, consider preparing some of your cardstock ahead of time using a color printer. Look for vintage-inspired Christmas illustrations, antique botanical prints, Victorian holiday designs, or reproductions of old-fashioned Christmas postcards. Printing these designs onto cream or ivory cardstock can give your tags a beautiful Old World Christmas appearance before anyone even picks up a pair of scissors. You can even print several coordinating designs on one sheet, leaving guests free to cut, layer, embellish, and personalize their tags with lace, ribbon, buttons, and other vintage treasures.
Step 1: Gather Your Supplies
Before you start shopping for supplies, take a little treasure hunt through your own home. Peek inside your sewing baskets, sort through old stationery, gather up leftover Christmas decorations, and don't forget those drawers where all the little odds and ends seem to end up. You might be surprised at how many wonderful materials you already have tucked away!
And if you don't have everything you need, don't worry. I've included some convenient shopping links throughout this post to help you find those missing supplies online. The idea is to get creative with what you have and only purchase what you need to bring your holiday gift tag workshop to life.
Paper and Cardstock
Old Christmas cards
Vintage or reproduced sheet music, articles and scrapbook paper
Damaged book pages
Leftover wallpaper
Brown paper grocery bags
Old calendars with beautiful illustrations
Unused stationery
For the sturdiest gift tags, use cardstock as your base and layer thinner papers over it.
If you're using old book pages or sheet music, consider photocopying particularly beautiful pages so you can preserve the originals.
Ribbons, Fabric, and Embellishments
One of my favorite things about working with vintage materials is that they don't have to match perfectly.
A faded floral pattern, a little cream-colored lace, and a piece of burgundy ribbon can look beautiful together, even if they came from completely different places.
Basic Tools
You'll also want scissors, a ruler, a pencil, a hole punch, a glue stick, double-sided tape, and a few tag templates.
Decorative-edge scissors, corner punches, and a paper cutter are helpful but certainly not necessary.
Step 2: Set Up Your Vintage Christmas Gift Tag Workshop Using Your Thrifted & Forgotten Treasures
You don't need a dedicated craft room or an enormous dining table.
A kitchen island, folding table, or cleared-off sideboard works perfectly.
The trick is to organize everything so guests can easily see what is available and move from one activity to the next.
Create Five Simple Work Areas
1. The Paper Station
Arrange your paper materials in shallow baskets, wooden trays, or vintage boxes.
Separate sturdy cardstock from decorative papers so everyone can easily choose a base and coordinating design.
2. The Cutting Station
Set out scissors, rulers, pencils, tag templates (I have a free download on the website), and hole punches.
Keep a small container nearby for paper scraps. Some of those little pieces may be perfect for another tag.
3. The Embellishment Station
This is where the fun really begins.
Fill small bowls, teacups, or divided trays with buttons, lace, ribbon, dried flowers, stamps, and other decorative pieces.
Mismatched vintage dishes make wonderful organizers and add a little charm to the table.
4. The Assembly Station
Provide glue sticks, double-sided tape, and a clean surface for putting everything together.
If you're using hot glue or wax seals, set up a separate heat-safe area with adult supervision.
5. The Finishing and Packaging Station
Set out cotton twine, ribbon, small envelopes, and paper bags so everyone can bundle their finished gift tags.
You could even provide little cards where guests can write their names or the year they created their tags.
Make the Workshop Feel Festive
A few evergreen branches, a bowl of pinecones, soft Christmas music, and a pot of something warm to drink can make an ordinary crafting afternoon feel like a special occasion.
Keep decorations toward the center or back of the table so they don't interfere with the workspace.
And remember, the supplies themselves are part of the decoration. A wooden tray filled with velvet ribbons and old-fashioned papers is already beautiful.
Step 3: Make Seven Different Styles of Vintage Christmas Gift Tags
Now for the creative part!
You can make all seven styles or choose just a few favorites.
For most gifts, tags measuring approximately 2½ × 4 inches work beautifully. Smaller tags are lovely for jars, ornaments, and little packages.
1. Antique Sheet Music Christmas Tags

There's a timeless charm to old sheet music, especially when paired with velvet ribbon and natural greenery.
You'll need:
How to make them:
Cut cardstock into your preferred gift tag shape.
Cut a piece of sheet music slightly smaller than the cardstock.
Glue the sheet music onto the tag, leaving a narrow border.
Punch a hole near the top.
Thread a piece of velvet ribbon or twine through the hole.
Add a small decorative detail, such as a stamped star or a tiny paper evergreen sprig.
For a softer, aged appearance, lightly distress the edges with brown ink.
These tags look especially beautiful on packages wrapped in plain brown paper.
2. Pressed Botanical Gift Tags

If you enjoy gardening, this is a lovely way to bring a little piece of the garden into your Christmas wrapping.
Pressed ferns, small leaves, and dried flower petals can create delicate botanical designs.
You'll need:
How to make them:
Cut cardstock into rectangular or oval gift tags.
Arrange your pressed botanicals on the paper before applying glue.
Use a small amount of clear-drying glue to secure each piece.
Allow the tags to dry completely.
Punch a hole at the top and add cotton twine.
For a more finished appearance, use a small piece of translucent vellum over the botanicals, securing it around the edges.
Garden tip: Flat, fully dried leaves and flowers work best. Fresh greenery can discolor, become brittle, or develop mold when enclosed in gift packaging.
3. Vintage Wallpaper Gift Tags

Those little wallpaper remnants left over from decorating projects can be surprisingly useful.
Look for faded florals, French country patterns, delicate stripes, and old-fashioned botanical designs.
You'll need:
How to make them:
Cut a sturdy cardstock base.
Select a wallpaper pattern and cut it slightly smaller than your tag.
Glue the wallpaper onto the cardstock.
Add a small strip of lace or ribbon across the bottom.
Punch a hole at the top.
Finish with coordinating ribbon.
If your wallpaper has a particularly beautiful floral design, try cutting around individual flowers and layering them onto plain cardstock. It's a simple technique that makes even small scraps useful.
4. Repurposed Christmas Card Tags

Before throwing away this year's Christmas cards, take another look at the illustrations.
Some of the prettiest gift tags can come from greeting cards that would otherwise end up in the recycling bin.
You'll need:
How to make them:
Look for illustrations that can be cut into smaller sections.
Cut around the image or use a rectangular tag template.
If the card is sturdy enough, use the illustration as your tag.
For thinner cards, glue the illustration onto cardstock.
Punch a hole at the top and add ribbon.
You can also combine several small illustrations into a collage.
A tiny bird, a sprig of holly, and a decorative border from different cards can become an entirely new design.
5. Linen and Lace Christmas Tags

If you have a sewing basket filled with leftover fabric, this project is a wonderful way to put those scraps to use.
You'll need:
How to make them:
Cut a sturdy cardstock base.
Trim a piece of linen slightly smaller than the tag.
Attach the fabric using a thin layer of fabric glue.
Add a narrow strip of lace across the bottom or one side.
Allow the glue to dry completely.
Punch a hole and finish with ribbon.
For an extra touch, add a tiny button or stamp the fabric with different holiday stamps.
These tags are especially pretty on gifts wrapped in natural linen, kraft paper, or reusable fabric.
6. Old-Fashioned Stamped Christmas Tags

Rubber stamps are wonderful for creating a coordinated collection of tags without making every one identical.
You'll need:
How to make them:
Cut your cardstock into tag shapes.
Choose a stamp featuring a botanical illustration, star, snowflake, or decorative border.
Press the stamp evenly onto the paper.
Allow the ink to dry.
Lightly distress the edges if desired.
Punch a hole and thread with twine.
Try using muted colors such as forest green, burgundy, brown, and charcoal rather than bright red and green.
The finished tags have a wonderfully understated vintage appearance.
7. Wax-Sealed Keepsake Gift Tags

For those special gifts that deserve a little extra attention, wax seals can turn a simple paper tag into something memorable. There's is a link below for wax sticks that go right in your glue gun. It's fast and easy without having to buy a lot of different accessories.
You'll need:
How to make them:
Cut a tag from heavy cardstock.
Add a decorative paper layer if desired.
Place the tag on a heat-safe surface.
Carefully melt sealing wax according to the manufacturer's instructions. There are also hot glue gun wax sticks that go right into your glue gun. Follow the manufacturers instructions if you choose this option as well.
Pour a small amount onto the tag.
Press the seal stamp into the warm wax.
Allow the wax to cool completely before lifting the stamp.
Add ribbon to finish.
For a special keepsake, consider stamping a family initial or a simple botanical design into the wax.
Safety note: Melted sealing wax and heating tools can cause burns. Keep this activity at a separate supervised station, away from children, loose paper, and flammable decorations. Adhesive-backed imitation wax seals are an easy alternative.
Step 4: Create a Few Coordinated Gift Tag Collections
Once everyone has experimented with the different techniques, try creating small collections that coordinate with particular wrapping styles.
Here are a few combinations to inspire you.
The Old-Fashioned Christmas Collection
Antique sheet music, burgundy velvet ribbon, cream cardstock, and simple evergreen illustrations.
The French Country Christmas Collection
Faded floral wallpaper, ivory lace, natural linen, and muted blue or sage-green ribbons.
The Woodland Christmas Collection
Kraft paper, pressed ferns, botanical stamps, cotton twine, and natural greenery.
The Victorian Christmas Collection
Repurposed Christmas card illustrations, decorative paper, gold accents, and wax seals.
The Simple Farmhouse Collection
Brown paper, cream cotton ribbon, hand-stamped designs, and small fabric scraps.
Creating collections makes it easier to coordinate your gift wrapping without purchasing matching supplies.
And if you have several gifts to wrap, making a dozen tags in the same style can save time later.
Step 5: Turn Your Workshop into a Holiday Gathering

One of the nicest things about this project is that it doesn't have to be something you do alone.
Invite a few friends, neighbors, or family members to spend an afternoon making gift tags together.
Ask everyone to bring a small bag of materials they no longer need.
Someone might bring leftover Christmas ribbon, another person may have beautiful greeting cards, and someone else might have an old box of buttons or fabric scraps.
Set everything out on the table and let everyone share.
You could even turn it into a little holiday tradition where everyone exchanges a few of their finished tags before heading home.
Serve Christmas cookies, warm cider, or a pot of your favorite winter tea.
There's no need for an elaborate party. Sometimes the simplest gatherings are the ones people remember.
A Fun Idea: The Mystery Materials Challenge
For a little extra entertainment, fill several small paper bags with random craft supplies.
Each bag might contain a piece of ribbon, a scrap of fabric, a button, a small illustration, and a piece of decorative paper.
Have everyone choose a bag without looking inside.
The challenge is to create a beautiful Christmas gift tag using only the materials in their bag, along with basic tools and adhesives.
It's a fun way to encourage creativity, and you might be surprised by what everyone comes up with.
Step 6: Package Your Handmade Gift Tags as Christmas Gifts

Handmade gift tags can be gifts themselves.
A small collection of six or twelve coordinating tags makes a lovely present for someone who enjoys wrapping gifts, crafting, or decorating for the holidays.
Bundle them with cotton twine or velvet ribbon, place them in a small kraft envelope, or tuck them into a vintage tin or basket.
You could also create a little Christmas Wrapping Companion Kit.
Include:
Six to twelve handmade gift tags
A spool of cotton twine
A few pieces of coordinating ribbon
Small decorative paper embellishments
A handwritten note
Package everything in a secondhand box, basket, or decorative tin.
It's a thoughtful, useful gift that doesn't require a large budget.
Step 7: Store Your Finished Tags for Years to Come
If you're making tags ahead of Christmas, keep them organized so they're ready when you begin wrapping gifts.
A shallow wooden box, vintage recipe tin, or divided craft organizer works beautifully.
Separate your tags by style or size and keep extra ribbon and twine nearby.
Store pressed botanical tags somewhere dry, away from direct sunlight and moisture.
For tags decorated with wax seals or delicate embellishments, place a piece of tissue paper between layers to prevent damage.
You might even save a few favorite tags each year as keepsakes.
Over time, you'll have a collection that tells its own little story about the Christmases you've celebrated and the people who helped create them.
A Little More Meaning Behind the Gift
What I love about setting up a vintage Christmas gift tag workshop using thrifted and forgotten treasures is the opportunity to turn ordinary little things into something beautiful and meaningful. Those leftover scraps of lace, mismatched buttons, old Christmas cards, and bits of ribbon that might otherwise be tossed aside suddenly have a purpose again. It's a wonderful reminder that creating something special doesn't have to cost a fortune. Sometimes the most charming holiday decorations and gifts come from using what we already have, adding a little imagination, and taking the time to make something by hand. And when you bring family and friends together around a table filled with these forgotten treasures, you're not just making gift tags. You're creating memories and perhaps even starting a new Christmas tradition.
So, before you head out to buy another package of Christmas gift tags, take a look around your home.
You may already have everything you need to create something beautiful.
Here's to a Christmas filled with creativity, resourcefulness, and handmade traditions worth keeping.
As Always, happy creating!!!
Jennifer
Keep the Holiday Creativity Going
If you enjoyed creating your own vintage Christmas gift tags, be sure to explore our "How to Make a Gift-Wrapping Station" tutorial.
Pair your handmade tags with a beautifully organized wrapping station, and you'll have everything you need to make this year's Christmas gifts feel a little more personal.

To give your handmade Christmas gift tags an authentic, Old-World appearance, try using a simple brown paint wash. This technique adds subtle discoloration and depth to the paper, creating the look of something that has naturally aged over time.
1. Prepare the edges. Gently tear the edges of your cardstock or decorative paper to create an uneven, weathered appearance.
2. Mix your paint wash. Add a small amount of brown acrylic craft paint to a little water, starting with approximately one part paint to five parts water. You want a thin, translucent wash rather than a solid coat of paint.
3. Apply the wash. Using a soft paintbrush, lightly brush the diluted paint across the paper. Work in small sections, allowing a little extra color to settle along the torn edges and any textured areas.
4. Dab away the excess. While the paint is still wet, gently blot the surface with a clean, dry towel. This removes most of the paint while leaving behind a soft, uneven brown tint. Avoid rubbing too hard, especially on thinner papers.
5. Add a touch of gold. Once the paper is completely dry, use a nearly dry brush to lightly apply metallic gold craft paint along the torn edges. A little goes a long way. You want a subtle, aged, gilded effect rather than a solid gold border.
6. Let dry and decorate. Allow the cardstock to dry completely, flatten it beneath a heavy book if necessary, and finish with your favorite Christmas embellishments.
My tip: Always test your paint wash on a scrap piece first. Different papers absorb water differently, and printed designs may bleed if the ink isn't water-resistant. For the most natural appearance, don't try to make the coloring perfectly even. Those little variations are what give the paper its character.



Comments